Posted by
(Jimmie) Blackhawke on Thursday, December 03, 2009 1:11:43 PM
The speech at West Point by President Obama on Dec 1, 2009 was one well anticipated by the American people. Whereas some listeners were pleased with his speech and its contents, there were others who were not. After digesting his remarks over a period of hours, my final assessment was that it was a strange, vague, uninspiring speech that sounded more like a lecture. If the intent was to rally the nation it fail way short of that goal.
Never once during the speech did he say the word “win.” Of course I must admit defining what is a “win” in a war like this is difficult if not impossible. So I don’t hold him to account on that. He also threw a bone to those who have been calling for additional troops in Afghanistan while in the same breath telling those who are against additional troops that they will come home after 18 months. The president caught a lot of heat on the 18 months statement from both left and right.
The president tried to explain his long delay in making his decision to send troops but it was not convincing to me. I believe he felt trapped and politically conflicted. An anti-war liberal president having to make such a serious decision about a military matter must have been very hard for him. Afterwards there were Republicans cheering his decision to inject 30K more troops into Afghanistan. Republicans should be very careful in supporting this decision too strongly, as it might come back to hurt them during the 2010 and 2012 elections. So far the Republicans have resisted being drawn into Democratic legislation and bills that are very unpopular among the general population. But if they show too strong a support on the additional troop surge and it all turns into one big disaster, the Democrats will blame the Republicans for sure.
Personally I think Afghanistan is and will be President Obama’s Vietnam. He said it isn’t, but I would not expect him to say anything different. I doubt if his heart was in the speech he gave, the words came but the underlying “fire” to rally the nation, just was not there. But he has committed himself and he is catching flak mostly from the radical left. But the president does not have to fear them or worry about losing their support because they will support and vote for him regardless of what he does against them.
So in my assessment the speech was uninspiring and academic, only time will tell if this president made the right decision. The voters in 2008 made a choice by electing Obama, the troops don’t get a choice, but lets hope they don’t suffer too much from the choice made by the voters.